CRM Switchboard Take the quiz
Your CRM personality

The Relationship Builder

You know your donors' kids' names. Your database should too.

For a nonprofit past spreadsheets and focused on keeping donors giving, our quiz recommends Bloomerang, Little Green Light or DonorPerfect. All three have verified or listed QuickBooks and Mailchimp integrations. Bloomerang starts at $125 a month, Little Green Light at $45, and DonorPerfect says its plans start at $119 a month.

  • Growing list
  • Modest monthly budget
  • Retention over bells and whistles
Retake the quiz

Best donor CRM for retention-focused small nonprofits

You're past spreadsheets and focused on keeping donors coming back. You want a classic donor-management CRM with solid accounting and email integrations, run by staff who aren't developers.

Your matches

CRMs that fit you

Bloomerang

Bloomerang

Donor-retention focus; verified QuickBooks and Mailchimp integrations.

Pricing

Bloomerang CRM from $125/month, Fundraising from $40/month and Volunteer from $119/month, billed annually, unlimited users. The bundled Giving Platform is 'contact sales for pricing' on the pricing page (Bloomerang's homepage FAQ still says it starts at $242/month; we treat that as unconfirmed).12

QuickBooks YesMailchimp YesFree migration offer

Little Green Light

Little Green Light

Priced by constituents with unlimited users; QuickBooks Online sync.

Pricing

$45/month up to 2,500 constituents; $60 up to 5,000; $75 up to 10,000; $90 up to 20,000; up to $135 for 50,000 (10% off billed annually). No charge for additional users.3

QuickBooks YesMailchimp YesFree migration offer

DonorPerfect

DonorPerfect

Long-running fundraising suite; QuickBooks and Mailchimp integrations listed.

Pricing

Plans start at $119/month, per DonorPerfect's homepage FAQ. The pricing page shows Core, Plus and Pro tiers with 'Get pricing' and a custom quote, and no visible price; an older 'starting at $99/month' banner is still in that page's code but hidden.45

QuickBooks YesMailchimp YesFree migration offer

Want help making the switch?

Free for nonprofits: we'll help you get connected to the migration firm that best suits your needs. We only share your request with your consent, with up to 3 firms.

Get matched
Migration guides

Guides for your likely move

All guides
Next steps

Get ready to switch

Meet the others

The other personalities

Results are rule-based and transparent. See the scoring. No vendor pays for placement.

Sources

  1. Bloomerang pricing · verified Oct 16, 2026
  2. Bloomerang homepage (pricing FAQ) · verified Oct 16, 2026
  3. Little Green Light pricing · verified Oct 16, 2026
  4. DonorPerfect homepage (FAQ: 'How much does DonorPerfect cost?') · verified Oct 16, 2026
  5. DonorPerfect pricing · verified Oct 16, 2026